5 Best Brown Mascara 2025

Laura Townsend Avatar

Published By

Best Brown Mascara

We thoroughly assess all products before recommending them. We may be compensated if you choose to buy through links on our site.

Brown mascara can be a subtle yet impactful way to enhance your eyes without overpowering your natural features. Unlike black mascara, which can be quite dramatic, brown mascara offers a more natural, softer look. Here are five top-rated brown mascaras that are perfect for achieving a natural, everyday look. Choosing the right brown mascara can depend on your personal preferences and desired level of drama. Some brown mascaras are more pigmented than others, while others are designed to provide a more subtle, natural look. It’s also important to consider factors such as your hair color, skin tone, and eye color when selecting a brown mascara. Check out The 5 best best brown mascaras below.

These mascaras are highly recommended for their ability to deliver both volume and length, while maintaining a natural, brown finish. They are also known for their quality ingredients and long-wearing formulas.

#1
Yves Saint Laurent lash clash extreme volume mascara

Best Overall

Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Extreme Volume

$32 Sephora

★★★★☆ 3,103 Reviews

Pros

  • Delivers dramatic volume and lift
  • Creamy formula prevents clumping
  • Curved brush for easy application

Cons

  • Can be a bit heavy for those with very fine lashes
  • May not be ideal for sensitive eyes

Yves Saint Laurent’s Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara is a luxurious formula designed to deliver dramatic, voluminous lashes. Its rich, creamy texture coats each lash evenly, preventing clumping and ensuring a smooth, even application. The curved brush expertly lifts and curls lashes, creating a wide-eyed effect that instantly draws attention. With Lash Clash, you can achieve a bold, glamorous look that’s sure to turn heads.

Why we love it

This is a classic mascara that delivers on its promise of dramatic lashes, even in a brown shade. It’s perfect for special occasions or whenever you want to make a statement.

Key Features

  • Extreme volume
  • Creamy formula
  • Curved brush

Customer Review

This mascara is absolutely gorgeous. I’ve tried so many over the years and this separates, lengthens with the perfect amount of volume. The brown is a true brown for those of us that are fair or really like a brown mascara.

#2
Lancome definicils high definition lengthening mascara

Best Low Smudge

Lancôme Définicils High Definition Lengthening

$34 Sephora

★★★★☆ 3423 Reviews

$34 Ulta Beauty

★★★★☆ 479 Reviews

$34 Amazon

★★★★☆ 2656 Reviews

Pros

  • Lengthens lashes without clumping
  • Lightweight and doesn’t flake or smudge
  • Precise applicator

Cons

  • May not provide as much volume as some other mascaras
  • Not suitable for those with very sensitive eyes

Lancôme’s Définicils High Definition Lengthening Mascara is a classic formula known for its ability to extend lashes without clumping. The lightweight texture ensures a comfortable, all-day wear, while the precise applicator helps to capture and lengthen each lash. With Définicils, you can achieve a natural, lifted look that enhances your eyes without being overly dramatic.

Why we love it

This is a great option for those who want to achieve a natural, lengthened look without overpowering their eyes.

Key Features

  • Lengthening formula
  • Lightweight and smudge-proof
  • Precise applicator

Customer Review

This is the best mascara I have ever used. Non clumping and lengthening. Very good for thinner lashes. I have tried so many different mascaras but have found them to be clumping and sticky. I highly recommend this product.

#3
Westman Atelier eye want you lengthening volumizing clean mascara

Best Vegan

Westman Atelier Eye Want You Lengthening

$45 Sephora

★★★★☆ 389 Reviews

Pros

  • Clean and vegan formula
  • Lengthens and volumizes lashes
  • Smudge-proof and long-wearing

Cons

  • May not be as dramatic as some other mascaras
  • Not suitable for those who prefer a very bold look

Westman Atelier’s Eye Want You Mascara is a luxurious clean beauty formula designed to deliver dramatic, lengthened lashes. The unique brush is shaped to capture and extend each lash, while the nourishing ingredients help to strengthen and condition them. Eye Want You is smudge-proof and long-wearing, ensuring your lashes stay looking their best throughout the day.

Why we love it

This mascara is perfect for those who want to achieve a natural, enhanced look without sacrificing performance.

Key Features

  • Clean and vegan formula
  • Lengthening and volumizing
  • Smudge-proof and long-wearing

Customer Review

I LOVE this shade of brown and the application…never clumpy! It is a more subtle/ everyday type of mascara (don’t expect this to look like lash extensions)but it gives the perfect ump for a natural look!

#4
Grande cosmetics grandemascara conditioning peptide mascara

Best Lengthening

Grande Cosmetics GrandeMASCARA

$25 Sephora

★★★★☆ 579 Reviews

$25 Ulta Beauty

★★★★☆ 933 Reviews

Pros

  • Lengthens and conditions lashes
  • Contains nourishing peptides
  • Smudge-proof and long-wearing

Cons

  • May not provide as much volume as some other mascaras
  • Not suitable for those with very sensitive eyes

Grande Cosmetics’ GrandeMASCARA is a nourishing formula designed to both lengthen and condition lashes. The innovative formula contains peptides that help to strengthen and hydrate lashes, promoting growth and preventing breakage. GrandeMASCARA is smudge-proof and long-wearing, ensuring your lashes stay looking their best throughout the day.

Why we love it

This is a great option for those who want to achieve a natural, lengthened look while also nourishing their lashes.

Key Features

  • Lengthening and conditioning
  • Contains peptides
  • Smudge-proof and long-wearing

Customer Review

Love this product…easy and beautiful application. Looks great. Doesn’t flake or clump and doesn’t run all day long!

#5
e.l.f. Cosmetics lash-n-roll curling lifting mascara

Best Affordable

e.l.f. Cosmetics Lash ‘N Roll Curling & Lifting

$6 Ulta Beauty

★★★★☆ 1739 Reviews

$6 Amazon

★★★★☆ 4502 Reviews

Pros

  • Lifts and curls lashes
  • Lightweight and doesn’t flake or smudge
  • Affordable price

Cons

  • May not provide as much volume as some other mascaras
  • Not suitable for those with very sensitive eyes

e.l.f. Cosmetics’ Lash ‘N Roll Mascara is an affordable option that delivers on its promise of lifting and curling lashes. The lightweight formula is easy to apply and doesn’t flake or smudge, ensuring a comfortable, all-day wear. With Lash ‘N Roll, you can achieve a natural, lifted look without breaking the bank.

Why we love it

This is a great budget-friendly option for those who want to achieve a natural, lifted look.

Key Features

  • Curling and lifting formula
  • Lightweight and smudge-proof

Customer Review

The product is good texture, not clumpy but thick enough to stick to lashes quickly, making application a quick process. The curved brush help curve lashes upward. my lashes are pretty straight and this product gives them a nice upward curve. recommend this!