What Are the Disadvantages of Lip Oil?

We thoroughly assess all products before recommending them. We may be compensated if you choose to buy through links on our site.

The Surprising Drawbacks of Your Favorite Lip Oil

We all adore the juicy, high-shine finish of a good lip oil. It promises the nourishing benefits of a balm with the stunning sheen of a gloss. Your social media feed is likely filled with glowing reviews and perfectly plump pouts. However, your favorite beauty product might have some hidden downsides. As a beauty editor, I have tested countless formulas and spoken with dermatologists about what really happens when you slick on that glossy oil. Understanding the potential disadvantages of lip oil helps you make smarter choices for your lip care routine.

These products are not all created equal, and some formulas can cause more problems than they solve. From short-lived hydration to potential skin irritation, the truth about lip oil is a bit more complicated than a simple swipe-and-go. Let’s explore the less-than-glamorous side of this trendy lip product so you can keep your smile healthy and beautiful.

The Illusion of Deep Hydration

One of the most significant disadvantages of lip oil is its limited ability to provide long-term moisture. Many people reach for lip oil thinking it is a superior hydrator, but its primary function is often cosmetic. Most lip oils are formulated with large oil molecules that cannot penetrate the delicate skin of your lips. Instead, they form an occlusive layer that sits on the surface. This layer feels smooth and comfortable initially, and it does a great job of trapping existing moisture. The high-shine finish also reflects light, making lips appear fuller and healthier. This immediate effect is what makes us love them so much. However, this surface-level barrier does little to deliver deep, lasting hydration to the underlying skin cells. It provides a temporary fix for dryness rather than a true solution.

This creates a cycle of dependency. When the oil wears off, your lips may feel just as dry as before, or sometimes even drier. Your lips did not absorb meaningful, restorative ingredients, so you feel the need to reapply the product constantly to maintain that comfortable, slick feeling. True lip hydration comes from ingredients called humectants, like hyaluronic acid or glycerin, which draw moisture into the skin. While some premium lip oils include these, many popular formulas do not. They rely solely on oils that seal but do not heal. A better approach involves using a true hydrating lip balm with humectants first, then layering a lip oil on top to lock in that moisture and add shine. This two-step process gives you the therapeutic benefits your lips need and the aesthetic finish you desire without leaving you in a constant loop of reapplication.

Related Article: Is Lip Oil Healthier Than Lip Gloss?
Related Article: All About Lip Oil

Potential for Irritation and Breakouts

While lip oils seem gentle and nourishing, certain ingredients within their formulas can trigger unwanted reactions. Many lip oils contain essential oils and fragrances to create a pleasant scent and taste. Ingredients like peppermint oil, citrus oils, and cinnamon are common culprits. They can cause contact dermatitis, an allergic reaction that results in redness, stinging, and peeling lips. What you perceive as a refreshing tingle might actually be low-level irritation. If your lips become more chapped or sensitive after using a scented lip oil, the fragrance could be the problem. Choosing fragrance-free options is a much safer bet for those with sensitive skin. Always check the ingredient list for potential irritants before you purchase a new product.

The skin around your mouth is also susceptible to issues. Some oils used in these formulas are comedogenic, meaning they can clog pores and lead to breakouts. If you are prone to acne or perioral dermatitis, a condition causing small bumps around the mouth, your lip oil might be exacerbating the issue. The product can easily migrate from your lips onto the surrounding skin, especially while you sleep. Oils like coconut oil, while popular in skincare, are moderately comedogenic and can be problematic for some individuals. Look for non-comedogenic oils like squalane, sunflower seed oil, or grapeseed oil to minimize this risk. Paying close attention to how your skin reacts is critical. If you notice new pimples or irritation around your lip line, your lip oil could very well be the source of the problem.

#1

Bobbi Brown Extra Plump Hydrating Lip Oil

Best Overall

$39 Nordstrom

★★★★☆ 320 Reviews

#2

Yves Saint Laurent YSL Loveshine Lip Oil Stick

Best Hydrating

$45 Sephora

★★★★☆ 2,619 Reviews

#3

Milk Makeup Odyssey Hydrating Non-Sticky

Best Shine

$26 Ulta Beauty

★★★★☆ 627 Reviews

The Problem with Longevity and Transfer

Let’s be honest: the staying power of most lip oils is minimal. Their thin, slippery consistency is a major factor in their poor longevity. A lip oil can disappear within an hour or two, and even faster if you are eating or drinking. That beautiful, glass-like shine you applied in the morning will likely be gone by the time you finish your first cup of coffee. This means you must commit to frequent touch-ups throughout the day to maintain the look. This constant reapplication can be inconvenient and cause you to go through the product very quickly, making it a less cost-effective choice compared to other lip products. If you need a look that lasts through a busy day or a special event, a lip oil is not the most reliable option.

The transfer issue is another practical disadvantage. Because of their slick nature, lip oils get on everything. They leave smudges on glasses, napkins, and the cheeks of anyone you kiss. This can be messy and frustrating to manage. Furthermore, on a windy day, your hair can easily get stuck to your lips, creating a sticky situation. This contrasts sharply with products like lip stains or matte liquid lipsticks, which are formulated to set and stay put for hours with minimal transfer. While a lip oil provides a comfortable feel, that comfort comes at the cost of durability. You must decide if the trade-off is worth it for your lifestyle. For a low-maintenance routine, a product that requires less attention might be a more suitable choice.

Sun Exposure and Environmental Impact

A glossy pout looks incredible in the sun, but it could also pose a risk. The high-shine finish of a lip oil can act like a magnifying glass for the sun’s harmful UV rays. This can potentially intensify your sun exposure and increase the risk of sun damage on your lips. The skin on your lips is incredibly thin and lacks melanin, making it highly vulnerable to sunburn and long-term damage, which can lead to premature aging and even skin cancer. Unfortunately, the vast majority of lip oils on the market do not contain any Sun Protection Factor (SPF).

Applying a shiny, non-protective layer could be worse than wearing nothing at all. To protect yourself, you should always apply a lip balm with at least SPF 30 before you layer a lip oil on top. This ensures your lips are shielded from UV radiation while still enjoying that coveted glossy effect.

Beyond personal health, we should also consider the environmental footprint of these popular products. Lip oils, like many cosmetics, often come in small plastic tubes with plastic applicators. This contributes to the growing problem of plastic waste in our environment. Because the product has poor longevity, consumers tend to use it up and dispose of the packaging more frequently. Some brands are making positive changes with refillable options or packaging made from recycled materials. As a conscious consumer, you can seek out these brands. By supporting companies that prioritize sustainability, you can enjoy your beauty routine while minimizing its impact on the planet. Your purchasing decisions can encourage more brands to adopt eco-friendly practices.

Limited Color Payoff and Versatility

If you love bold, vibrant lip color, a lip oil might leave you feeling disappointed. One of the main disadvantages of lip oil is its characteristically sheer pigment. Most formulas offer only a subtle hint of color that enhances your natural lip tone rather than providing opaque coverage. While this creates a beautiful, natural-looking tint, it is not ideal for someone who wants to make a statement with their lip color. You will not achieve the same color impact with a lip oil that you would with a traditional lipstick or a pigmented gloss. The color that is present can also wear off unevenly, leaving a patchy or faded appearance as the oil itself disappears. This lack of pigment limits the product’s versatility in your makeup collection.

Because of their sheer nature, lip oils are not effective at covering imperfections on the lips, such as discoloration or uneven tone. A lipstick, on the other hand, can provide full coverage to create a smooth, uniform canvas. Lip oils are best suited for days when you want a minimal, “your lips but better” look. They work well as a topper over other lip products, like a lip stain or liner, to add shine and a touch of moisture. However, when used alone, their function is quite specific. Anyone looking for a single product to deliver both intense color and a glossy finish will likely find lip oil to be insufficient for their needs. It excels at shine but falls short on pigment.

How to Choose and Use Lip Oils Effectively

Despite their disadvantages, lip oils can still be a wonderful addition to your routine if you know how to select the right one and use it correctly. The key is to become a savvy label reader. When shopping, prioritize formulas with genuinely nourishing, non-comedogenic ingredients. Look for lip oils that feature squalane, jojoba oil, sunflower seed oil, and hyaluronic acid. These ingredients support the skin barrier and help with true hydration. You should try to avoid products with potential irritants, especially if you have sensitive skin. Pay close attention to the following ingredients:

• Fragrance and Flavoring

  Synthetic fragrances and strong essential oils like peppermint or cinnamon can cause irritation and allergic reactions for many people.

• Certain Occlusive Agents

  While some occlusives are fine, heavy oils or silicones can feel heavy and may not let your skin breathe, potentially leading to clogged pores around the mouth.

• Alcohol

  Some formulas may include drying alcohols, which will counteract any hydrating benefits the oil might offer, leaving your lips more chapped over time.

To overcome the issue of poor longevity and hydration, rethink how you apply your lip oil. Instead of using it as a standalone treatment, use it as the final step in your lip care. First, gently exfoliate your lips to remove any dry skin. Next, apply a deeply hydrating lip balm or serum that contains humectants. Allow it to absorb for a minute. Then, apply your chosen lip oil on top. This technique, known as “lip layering” or “lip slugging,” allows the balm to provide the core hydration while the oil seals everything in and delivers that beautiful shine. This method gives you the best of both worlds: long-lasting moisture and a glossy finish.

Conclusion

Ultimately, lip oils are a fantastic cosmetic product for achieving a specific look. They offer unparalleled shine and a comfortable, non-sticky feel that many people love. However, it is important to recognize their limitations. They are not a cure-all for dry, chapped lips and may not provide the deep, lasting hydration your lips truly need. By understanding the potential disadvantages—from their short wear time to the possibility of irritation—you can use them more intelligently. Always prioritize lip health by choosing well-formulated products, protecting your lips from the sun, and using lip oil as a finishing touch rather than a primary treatment. With the right approach, you can enjoy the glossy benefits without any of the drawbacks.